With Pretty Little Liars returning this week and Shay Mitchell’s surprise appearance on what seemed like the ultimate It-girl vacation, our fangirl status for the actress has, admittedly, started to multiply. We can’t help scrolling through her Instagram, liking snap after snap of statement jewels, edgy sunglasses, and a variety of funny graphic t-shirts. We wouldn’t expect anything less from the second half of Amore and Vita: Shay’s got style, and lots of it. Keep on scrolling to view some of our favorite looks.